The
Philosophising Farmer
Carbon,
Chlorine, Cash & Sacred Cows
We've been contacted again by our mate out on the land in Queensland and
it seems he's been having a bit of a chuckle at the carry on down in Canberra.
He reckons with all the hoopla created over the big conference in Copenhagen
and the political carry-on connected to the whole subject of a carbon emissions
trading scheme, it seemed like a good idea to sit back and chew on the subject
for a bit. We agree, so we hope you
enjoy the second installment of
The Philosophising Farmer.
Did you know
that in the time of the dinosaurs the levels of carbon dioxide and oxygen in
our atmosphere were many times greater than today?
Carbon exists
as part of a continuum of being. It
resides within the earth's crust as minerals and organic deposits such as oil
and gas. These can be naturally or
artificially released through burning, and the carbon in the atmosphere is gases
are photo synthetically harvested back into living organisms and
finally taken as sediment back to the earth as deposits or released
back to the atmosphere as gases.
In the known
Universe it is the fourth most common element (by mass) after hydrogen, helium
& oxygen. Carbon forms more compounds than any other element with the
"organic" compounds being the largest group.
It is this
incredible capacity to form literally tens of millions of differing organic
compounds that makes carbon so valuable and so dangerous.
In its
elemental form carbon creates some unique crystalline forms, known as allotrope. The various allotropes
include graphite, diamond and amorphous carbon.
Each of these
possesses differing characteristics, for instance, diamond is hard, translucent
and a strong thermal conductor but poor electrical conductor while graphite is
soft, opaque and a good electrical conductor. Allotropes are strongly resistant
to biological reactions and are generally chemically non reactive.
Carbon is also
found as mineral deposits and may appear as inorganic salts or as carbonates in
limestone and chalk. Many carbon
compounds occur through natural chemical or biological reactions but equally as
many do not appear to be "naturally" derived. Combined with hydrogen & oxygen and sulphur and many others, carbon
forms 'organic' molecules. When carbon
forms simple compounds such as oxides, sulphates, cyanides they are generally
regarded as 'inorganic 'compounds.
The
distribution of carbon compounds throughout the biosphere of earth is
constantly changing and evolving over time. Where carbon has been unnaturally combined with other elements, we have
managed to create a bit of chemical chaos that has certainly been damaging to
the environment.
For instance,
chlorine is present as salts of potassium and sodium found coursing through our
veins as chlorides and in abundance in the oceans.
Chlorine in
combination with carbon as a naturally occurring organic compound is a rarity
but some time around World War II the potent effect of chlorine as a weapon was
discovered. Chlorine compounds are often extremely effective in killing life,
for instance Chlorine gas was used in the trenches.
Synthetically
derived combinations of chlorine with carbon were discovered to make even more
powerful biological killers, and these were compounds that could not be easily
broken down.
Over the past
40 years the complexity of carbon compounds has evolved with alarming
speed. Industry began producing
pesticides DDT, BHC Aldrins and other "organochlorines' that were promoted as
being real salvation for various sectors, including farming and agriculture.
Over time it became apparent this use of
'organochlorines' was fraught with dangers.
Dioxin was
produced accidentally in the synthesis of 2, 4,5T (a defoliant used in
Vietnam). The incidence of cancers and other physiological defects continues
today as a result of its use.
Today industry
continues to synthesize millions of tonnes of organic chlorine compounds like
many of the plastics (PVC), bactericides etc. Unknown are the thousands of
accidentally made new molecules also produced into the earth's biosphere. It is the long term downstream impact on all
organisms including mutations in the microorganism ecosystem that creates the
real concern.
These
materials are not natural to the biological pathways that have evolved over the
last tens of millions of years. Now they have been introduced into the carbon
cycle has "Pandora's box" been opened and the lid left open.
In our bid to
ramp up production on the land, eliminate competition and enhance the level of
convenience in our lives, we have created and released materials that pose a
serious long term impact on all living organisms.
I am not sure
an Emissions Trading Scheme is going to address these broader issues, but
surely one thing is certain. Slowing the
overall rate of pollution has to be a good, whether you agree with climate
change being man made or not. The
agenda needs to be broadened to eliminate the idea of carbon as the issue. It is not the problem; it is merely the
sacred cow being set down before the taxation altar.